Biology discovers arXiv (sort of)

Last year when Dr. Joseph Pickrell posted Why publish science in peer-reviewed journals? at Genomes Unzippedmany of the responses naturally turned to criticism of such a system which overturned the conventions of publication in biology. The critiques were fair enough, but my own confusion and irritation was with the fact that many seemed to pretend, or not know, about arXiv. It is perhaps true that biological sciences are different in some fundamental ways from physics, or even social sciences which put preprints up at SSRN. But it seems that any objection to the revolution in scientific production and dissemination which Dr. Pickrell proposed should at least grapple with the fact that physics, mathematics, computer science, economics, etc. continue to remain viable academic fields despite the fact that preprints circulate widely among scholars, and even to the general public.* Publication in a paper in these fields is often an after the ...