Register for an account

X

Enter your name and email address below.

Your email address is used to log in and will not be shared or sold. Read our privacy policy.

X

Website access code

Enter your access code into the form field below.

If you are a Zinio, Nook, Kindle, Apple, or Google Play subscriber, you can enter your website access code to gain subscriber access. Your website access code is located in the upper right corner of the Table of Contents page of your digital edition.

Mind

Year's Best Peer Review Comments: Papers That "Suck the Will to Live"

DiscoblogBy Jennifer WelshDecember 15, 2010 9:29 PM

Newsletter

Sign up for our email newsletter for the latest science news

peer-review.jpg

Peer review: love it or hate it, it's an integral part of every scientist's life. The reviews are usually kept secret, but the editors over at Environmental Microbiology like to give a little back during the holidays, and have gifted the internet with a list of some of their favorite quotes from peer reviews done this year:

Our referees, the Editorial Board Members and ad hoc reviewers, are busy, serious individuals who give selflessly of their precious time to improve manuscripts submitted to Environmental Microbiology. But, once in a while, their humour (or admiration) gets the better of them. Here are some quotes from reviews made over the past year, just in time for the Season of Goodwill and Merriment.

Here are some of our favorite catty reviewer quotes from this year's list:

  • This paper is desperate. Please reject it completely and then block the author's email ID so they can't use the online system in future.

  • The biggest problem with this manuscript, which has nearly sucked the will to live out of me, is the terrible writing style.

  • Ken, I would suggest that EM is setting up a fund that pays for the red wine reviewers may need to digest manuscripts like this one. (Ed.: this excellent suggestion was duly proposed to the Publisher. However, given the logistical difficulties of problem-solving within narrow time frames, combined with the known deleterious effect of transport on good wine, a modification of the remedy was adopted, namely that Editors would act as proxies for reviewers with said digestive complaints.)

  • I agreed to review this MS [manuscript] whilst answering e-mails in the golden glow of a balmy evening on the terrace of our holiday hotel on Lake Como. Back in the harsh light of reality in Belfast I realize that it's just on the limit of my comfort zone and that it would probably have been better not to have volunteered.

  • I suppose that I should be happy that I don't have to spend a lot of time reviewing this dreadful paper; however I am depressed that people are performing such bad science.

  • The presentation is of a standard that I would reject from an undergraduate student. Take Table 1: none of the data has units or an explanation. Negative controls gave a positive signal, but there is no explanation of why and how this was dealt with; just that it was different.

  • The lack of negative controls. . . . results in the authors being lost in the funhouse. Unfortunately, I do not think they even realize this.

  • Reject – More holes than my grandad's string vest!

  • The writing and data presentation are so bad that I had to leave work and go home early and then spend time to wonder what life is about.

Hit this link

to view the whole long list. Can't get enough? Check out last year's

picks. Related Content: Discoblog: NCBI ROFL: Snappy answers to stupid questions: an evidence-based framework for responding to peer-review feedback.

Discoblog: What Kind of Peer-Review Would Jesus Want?

80beats: ClimateGate Inquiry: No Scientific Misconduct From “Squeaky Clean” Researchers

The Intersection: Citizens Against Peer Review

Gene Expression: Peer review sucks?

Not Exactly Rocket Science: Arsenic bacteria – a post-mortem, a review, and some navel-gazing

Image: flickr / gingerpig2000

    2 Free Articles Left

    Want it all? Get unlimited access when you subscribe.

    Subscribe

    Already a subscriber? Register or Log In

    Want unlimited access?

    Subscribe today and save 70%

    Subscribe

    Already a subscriber? Register or Log In