We have completed maintenance on DiscoverMagazine.com and action may be required on your account. Learn More

Is It Possible to Systematically Turn Gay People Straight?

A century of treatments have ranged from horrifying to horribly unscientific.

By Melissa Lafsky
Sep 9, 2009 12:00 AMApr 17, 2023 9:01 PM
LGBTQ+ flag
(Credit: Cristina Moliner/Getty Images)


Sign up for our email newsletter for the latest science news

Joseph Nicolosi, a psychologist in Encino, Calif., says he can rid adults, teens, and even children of homosexuality. For nearly 30 years, he has offered a "psychodynamic" form of reparative therapy for people — mostly men — seeking to change their sexual orientation.

"If [a patient] can accept his bodily homoerotic experience while staying connected to the therapist," he wrote in The Paradox of Self-Acceptance, "the sexual feeling soon transforms into something else: the recognition of deeper, pain-generated emotional needs which have nothing to do with sexuality."

He cites the following case: A 43-year-old married accountant was recalling another man that he had seen at the airport while on a business trip. "This had awakened his sexual fantasies and dreams. I asked him to hold onto that image and observe his bodily sensations while staying connected to me. As he did, he felt an intense sexual longing. But as he followed that fantasy through an imaginary sexual scenario, quite unexpectedly, he then experienced an embodied shift to sadness, longing, and emptiness. In tears, he spoke of his sense of deep unworthiness. 'I would just love him to be my friend! He's the kind of guy that I always wanted to be close to. How much I just want to be friends with a guy like him.'"

All the major psychiatric organizations, including the American Psychological Association and the American Psychiatric Association, have warned against therapies that try to change sexual orientation. Both APAs have ruled that these therapies are unscientific and possibly harmful — not to mention unnecessary, since homosexuality was officially de-classified as an illness in 1973, and therefore can't be "cured." As such, sexual orientation change efforts (SOCE) are rarely practiced by mainstream mental health practitioners, while many therapists are concerned that anyone who does try to change through therapy may do themselves more harm than good.

Still, practices like Nicolosi's have persisted, as has the debate over whether sexual orientation can — or should — be changed. So on August 5, the APA's Council of Representatives took the strongest stand yet, passing a near-unanimous resolution urging mental health professionals not to tell clients that they can change their sexual orientation through therapy or any other methods.

The paper presented at the APA meeting was "the most thorough comprehensive review of the literature ever done, and used the highest standards of analysis," says Judith Glassgold, a psychologist who led the task force. It covered every major peer-reviewed study on SOCE conducted between 1960 and 2007, and found "serious methodological problems" with almost all of them. The few that did have "high-quality" evidence "show that enduring change to an individual's sexual orientation is uncommon," and that treatments intended to change sexual orientation may cause harm, including depression and mental distress.

The Dark Ages

Homosexuality was officially labeled a mental illness in the U.S. in the 1950s. The debate over same-sex attraction was not new: Sigmund Freud reported on one deliberate attempt to change the sexual orientation of a young woman who'd been brought in for involuntary treatment by her parents. He was unsuccessful, and concluded that attempts to change homosexual orientation were likely to fail.

Experimental treatments were performed throughout the mid-century, sometimes in high profile cases. In 1952, renowned mathematician Alan Turing was convicted of gross indecency in the U.K. after admitting to a sexual relationship with a man, and was forced to submit to estrogen injections as a form of "experimental chemical castration." Two years later, he committed suicide.

Throughout the 1960s and into the mid-70s, treatments in the U.S. mostly consisted of aversion therapy — teaching subjects to associate a strong feeling of dislike or disgust with same-sex attraction until the attraction disappeared. Given that homosexual activity was also criminally prosecuted in the U.S. at that time, the majority of people seeking to change were men who either faced prosecution or feared facing it in the future.

One of the most popular aversion techniques was "orgasmic reconditioning" — men would be shown erotic pictures of other men, and if they became aroused, they would receive an electric shock on their genitals. Therapists also gave patients drugs that induced vomiting or paralysis, or exposed them to noxious chemicals like ammonia, whenever they were aroused by same-sex photos. Some aversion treatments included rewards — including pleasant smells — for arousal in response to pictures of women.

There was also shame aversion therapy, first used in the 1930s, which involved continually subjecting the patient to public shame or humiliation over his same-sex arousal. Another method was satiation therapy, in which a subject was told to masturbate over and over while verbally describing his homosexual fantasies, until they disappeared — or, at least, diminished.

These "therapies" were generally ineffective — the person remained attracted to the same sex — or over-effective — the person was traumatized and lost all sexual arousal entirely. They "were used without people thinking about whether they were humane," Glassgold says.

Not all treatments were so gruesome: Lionel Ovesey, a Columbia University psychoanalyst and author of Homosexuality and Pseudohomosexuality, created a behavioral method in the 1960s. It was based on the idea that homosexuality originated from a fear of taking on the normal qualities of one's gender. Ovesey studied a clinically disturbed group of patients and summarized their unconscious minds as follows: "I am a failure = I am not a man = I am castrated = I am a woman = I am a homosexual." His view mirrored the belief of many clinicians at the time: that homosexuality was based on a phobia of the opposite sex.

Other non-aversive treatments following this theory focused on building "educational skills" like dating techniques, assertiveness training, and affection coaching to increase interactions with women. Also encouraged: plenty of heterosexual intercourse. Cognitive therapists, meanwhile, made a few attempts to change homosexuals' thought patterns by reframing desires — redirecting thoughts away from homosexual activity — or through hypnosis.

"Changing" Sexuality Today

Befitting the times, the mainstream mental health community no longer advocates change treatments, but instead supports approaches that help patients cope with the stress and stigma of being a sexual minority. Still, SOCE is still being practiced within a small group of mental-health practitioners, most of whom cater to a population whose religious beliefs strictly bar homosexuality.

1 free article left
Want More? Get unlimited access for as low as $1.99/month

Already a subscriber?

Register or Log In

1 free articleSubscribe
Discover Magazine Logo
Want more?

Keep reading for as low as $1.99!


Already a subscriber?

Register or Log In

More From Discover
Recommendations From Our Store
Shop Now
Stay Curious
Our List

Sign up for our weekly science updates.

To The Magazine

Save up to 40% off the cover price when you subscribe to Discover magazine.

Copyright © 2024 Kalmbach Media Co.