This week in Nature Geoscience, a cadre of scientists going by the name Global Carbon Project will publish a meta-analysis of global carbon emissions. The study led to headlines like, "Global CO2 emissions to drop 2.8 pct in '09: report," and many others more in the ominous vein of "Earth 'heading for 6C (6 degrees Celsius)' of warming." So how did both headlines come from the same study? This year's dip is correct: