skip to main content

Most Pandemic Viruses Show No Signs of Lab Adaptation — Except This One Historical Outbreak

Learn how scientists identified genetic clues that distinguish natural viral spillovers from lab-handled viruses — and why one historical outbreak of 1977 surprised them.

Written byStephanie Edwards
| 3 min read
Follow on Google
Illustration of coronavirus particles representing a COVID-19 mutation
Coronavirus mutation.(Image Credit: peterschreiber.media/Shutterstock)

Newsletter

Sign up for our email newsletter for the latest science news

Sign Up

There has been much debate, from scientists and the general public alike, about the origins of some of our planet’s most devastating pandemics. Now, a new genetic analysis of major outbreak viruses is challenging a long-held assumption about how pandemics start.

According to research published in Cell, many viruses that jump from animals to humans may already be capable of infecting people without undergoing special evolutionary changes beforehand. This finding reshapes how scientists think about zoonotic diseases and also provides a new tool for investigating the origins of outbreaks, including the virus behind COVID-19.

“This work has direct relevance to the ongoing controversy around COVID-19 origins,” said senior author Joel Wertheim in a press release. “From an evolutionary perspective, we find no evidence that SARS-CoV-2 was shaped by selection in a laboratory or prolonged evolution in an intermediate host prior to its emergence. That absence of evidence is exactly what we would expect from a natural zoonotic event — and it represents another nail in the coffin for theories invoking laboratory manipulation.”


Read More: A New Vaccine Platform Could Cut Development Timelines From Months to Weeks


How Scientists Can Tell a Virus Didn’t Come From a Lab

For years, many scientists believed that animal viruses had to accumulate specific mutations before they could successfully spread among humans. But the new study suggests that assumption doesn’t hold up.

Discover Magazine Logo

You have 1 more free article (1 of 2)

Have an account? log in

Subscribe today for full access and support our journalism.

checkmarkExplore All Options

The research team conducted a large phylogenetic analysis of viral genomes from multiple outbreaks, including Influenza A virus, Ebola virus, Marburg virus, Mpox virus, SARS-CoV-2, and SARS-CoV-1. They focused specifically on the evolutionary window just before each virus began spreading among humans. If viruses had undergone significant adaptation before infecting people, those changes would leave detectable signatures in their genomes. But the researchers didn’t find that signal.

Instead, the selection pressures shaping viruses before they infected humans looked essentially the same as those seen during normal circulation in animal reservoirs. Only after viruses began spreading widely among people did new evolutionary patterns emerge.

“From a broad epidemiological standpoint, our findings challenge the idea that pandemic viruses are evolutionarily special before they reach humans. Rather than requiring rare, finely tuned adaptations in animals, many viruses already possess the basic capacity to infect and transmit between humans. What matters most is human exposure to a diverse array of animal viruses,” explained Wertheim.

To confirm their method worked, the researchers also analyzed viruses that were deliberately propagated in laboratory environments, such as in cell cultures or laboratory animals. Those viruses produced distinctive genetic signatures — exactly the kind scientists would expect to see if a pathogen had been heavily manipulated.

The Strange Case of the 1977 Influenza

While most viruses in the study followed the same natural pattern, one historical outbreak stood out.

When researchers examined the strain responsible for the 1977 resurgence of the H1N1 influenza virus, they found something unusual. The virus was nearly identical to strains circulating in the 1950s. Even more surprising, its evolutionary signature resembled the study’s control viruses that had been grown in laboratory conditions.

“The 1977 influenza story is, in many ways, even more compelling than what we found for COVID-19,” said Wertheim. “Our results provide new molecular evidence supporting the long-suspected idea that the H1N1 pandemic was sparked by a laboratory strain — possibly in the context of a failed vaccine trial.”

A New Tool for Future Outbreaks

Beyond revisiting historical outbreaks, the researchers say their framework could help scientists evaluate future pandemics more quickly and objectively. By establishing what typical zoonotic spillover looks like at the genomic level, scientists now have a clearer baseline for comparison when new viruses emerge.

“Our goal is not just to understand the past, but to be better prepared for the future. By clarifying how pandemics actually begin, we can focus attention where it belongs — on surveillance, prevention, and reducing the opportunities for the constant barrage of viral spillover,” concluded Wertheim.

This article is not offering medical advice and should be used for informational purposes only.


Read More: What Makes the Subclade K Strain Different? Here’s What to Know About the “Super Flu”


Article Sources

Our writers at Discovermagazine.com use peer-reviewed studies and high-quality sources for our articles, and our editors review for scientific accuracy and editorial standards. Review the sources used below for this article:

Meet the Author

  • Stephanie Edwards
    Stephanie Edwards is the Engagement Specialist at Discover Magazine, who manages all social media platforms and writes digital articles that focus on archaeology, the environment, and public health.View Full Profile

Related Topics

Stay Curious

JoinOur List

Sign up for our weekly science updates

View our Privacy Policy

SubscribeTo The Magazine

Save up to 40% off the cover price when you subscribe to Discover magazine.

Subscribe